The Nemes Challenge
Posted: Sat Apr 25, 2015 7:37 pm
Good Evening Forum Friends,
I was reading with great interest recently some comments by Dave Hughes in his great book "Wet Flies" that the action in a soft-hackled fly is in the hackle. And in the same way, the action in a flymph is in the body of the fly! I think that Syl also commented and indeed challenged each one of his readers in one of his wonderful books (sorry, I can't remember exactly which one at this moment) to tie and fish an all hackle pattern, no body at all! The pictures below are my latest attempt at such and I was just wondering if anyone has taken up this challenge beforehand? I have but it was years ago. I found a battered old beast in the very corner of my wet fly box and I thought about these words and so I tied a few in size 12. My intentions are to try them soon and get back with you-all. Does anyone want to take up the challenge with me for fun and enlightenment?
A Stewart Spider is very close to an all hackle, no body fly pattern and I have had tremendous success with them! Here is the shortest recipe ever for a fly pattern (the all hackle!)
Hook: TMC 3761 size 12 or 14
Thread: Danvilles 6/0 dark maroon (I think it's listed as sherry?)
Hackle: Darkest, speckled Hungarian Partridge. Lighter hackles from the breast or around the neck would also do well. I happen to love the darker ones more!
Wax: Just a single run thru of Bill's tying wax over the first 6" or so of the tying thread. It helps tremendously!
Head Cement (optional because of the wax's tackiness): Loon clear water-based head cement used sparingly on the head only!
Enjoy and report back soon!
Doug
I was reading with great interest recently some comments by Dave Hughes in his great book "Wet Flies" that the action in a soft-hackled fly is in the hackle. And in the same way, the action in a flymph is in the body of the fly! I think that Syl also commented and indeed challenged each one of his readers in one of his wonderful books (sorry, I can't remember exactly which one at this moment) to tie and fish an all hackle pattern, no body at all! The pictures below are my latest attempt at such and I was just wondering if anyone has taken up this challenge beforehand? I have but it was years ago. I found a battered old beast in the very corner of my wet fly box and I thought about these words and so I tied a few in size 12. My intentions are to try them soon and get back with you-all. Does anyone want to take up the challenge with me for fun and enlightenment?
A Stewart Spider is very close to an all hackle, no body fly pattern and I have had tremendous success with them! Here is the shortest recipe ever for a fly pattern (the all hackle!)
Hook: TMC 3761 size 12 or 14
Thread: Danvilles 6/0 dark maroon (I think it's listed as sherry?)
Hackle: Darkest, speckled Hungarian Partridge. Lighter hackles from the breast or around the neck would also do well. I happen to love the darker ones more!
Wax: Just a single run thru of Bill's tying wax over the first 6" or so of the tying thread. It helps tremendously!
Head Cement (optional because of the wax's tackiness): Loon clear water-based head cement used sparingly on the head only!
Enjoy and report back soon!
Doug