Carl,Re: Some soft hackles
by Old Hat » ndam30. AprilUTCb 23, 2009 08:28 p04
The emerger intrigues me. I see this design a lot and have tried it often but have never had any luck with it.
I have found this to be the best mayfly emerger pattern I've ever used.
To illustrate a recent incident; about a month ago I was in Tasmania fishing a stream in the Derwent Valley. First day we saw plenty of fish nymphing just under the surface in open water in fact in all parts of the water. We couldn't detect significant numbers of flies on the water or in the air but we tried many different patterns, which ordinarily would work in Australia, but nothing worked. It wasn't until I climbed in the water and screened the drift that we found small shucks of #18 olive nymphs in large numbers. I looked in my fly box and found a small olive CDC emerger fly which looked just like them. To test it I fished it under a dry fly for the indicator since I started fishing a run in the head of a pool where the water was quite rough. The fly was impossible to see as it was taken down into the water column. it was very soon that I hooked the first trout of the day. My fishing companion was impressed but his eyes popped after I extracted the second fish from the same run. From then on it was one after the other and it soon became clear that the CDC emerger drifting in the water was the key.
Here's one of those fish.

Then last weekend a river known for black mayflies which were hatching. iIt was clear the same fly in black was needed. Selected fish were taking emergers and duns from the film in the bubble lines and the same fly in black did the trick over and over again that weekend. There was no need for the dry as indicator, in this case the water was quite slow and placid so the emerger was visible in the film. You can see the water slowly moving and the foam line on the right wher the fish were working.


A slow eddie where the fish were mopping up the duns and emergers at leisure.

The result...

It just works, the trick is make them slim. The body below the surface and the CDC in the film or just above it makes it a perfect 'trigger' fly and a good representation of an emergering mayfly. One thing I did learn from experience is that the amount of CDC is important to how the fly swims. Too much and it sits too high and starts to look too bulky, too little and you can't see the fly as it will sink.

Give it a try.